Answer to Job
When dealing with the contradictions in the Bible, this book is on fire. Its main interpretation of the Book of Job has changed the way I think about it. However, as one of the early psychoanalysts, Jung applies his garbage theory in barely readable pose. Sometimes it was so convoluted I read sentences and paragraphs several times over and still couldnt quite figure what he was saying. In short, this is occasionally insightful, but for the most part is schlock and a dreadful read.
The back cover advertises Answer to Job as "one of Jung's most controversial works." He wrote it toward the end of his life, in the early 1950s, and according to the introduction to the 2010 edition by Sonu Shamdasani, he composed it in a kind of fever and later considered it the only one of his works he would not wish to alter. A short, swift book, written in a dryly sardonic style, it is a plea to update Christianity, or monotheism more generally, so that it can face the dangers of the atomic
Even now after having just finished the book I find myself equally confused and apathetic toward the entire process of reading it. I thought that Rogers was tangential in his writing but this is even worse. I was afraid that the introduction notes were a sign of what was to come, and my fears were well established halfway through the book.From the best of what I understand, Jung psychoanalyzed God and Christianity, but with his own brand of psychoanalysis or analysis or whatever it was. For
The short answer is that God's answer to Job was "Jesus Christ". However, Jung takes 140 pages to give the long answer, which will lose or bewilder traditional Christians. If you are "Jung at heart", though, these ideas should not be too surprising: that the psyche is real, that God is reality itself, and that God was found to be incomplete by Job's inquiry, fueling God's desire to become man in the flesh. This is not easy reading, but then, I don't know of anyone else who has given the question
In Jung's dense and wild meditation on Christianity, published nine years before his death, he seeks some lofty antecedents, but lets his fast and loose language of archetype cover for some questionable footwork.Jung clearly built his book as an homage to Kierkegaard's Fear and Trembling, substituting the philosopher's exegesis of Isaac and Abraham for an inquiry into the nature of Job. For Kierkegaard, several Rashoman-like retellings of the story eventually yield to furious, brooding analysis
Not an easy book to read, as Jung was overfond of technical terms such as "chthonic" and "quaternity." Still, after having encountered the Old Testament God in the Book of Job, I was greatly disturbed by His capriciousness and even amorality. Jung helped explain how the misbehavior of Yahweh led eventually to Christianity.
C.G. Jung
Paperback | Pages: 144 pages Rating: 4.15 | 1212 Users | 127 Reviews
Specify Books During Answer to Job
Original Title: | Antwort auf Hiob |
ISBN: | 0691017859 (ISBN13: 9780691017853) |
Edition Language: | English |
Characters: | Job |
Narrative In Pursuance Of Books Answer to Job
Jung has never pursued the "psychology of religion" apart from general psychology. The unique importance of his work lies rather in his discovery and treatment of religious, or potentially religious, factors in his investigation into the unconscious as a whole and in his general therapeutic practice. In Answer to Job, first published in Zurich in 1952, Jung employs the familiar language of theological discourse. Such terms as "God," "wisdom," and "evil" are the touchstones of his argument. And yet, Answer to Job, perhaps Jung's most controversial work, is not an essay in theology as much as it is an examination of the symbolic role that theological concepts play in a person's psychic life.Present Based On Books Answer to Job
Title | : | Answer to Job |
Author | : | C.G. Jung |
Book Format | : | Paperback |
Book Edition | : | 50th Anniversary Edition |
Pages | : | Pages: 144 pages |
Published | : | May 1st 1973 by Princeton University Press (NJ) (first published 1952) |
Categories | : | Psychology. Philosophy. Religion. Nonfiction. Spirituality. Theology. Christianity |
Rating Based On Books Answer to Job
Ratings: 4.15 From 1212 Users | 127 ReviewsColumn Based On Books Answer to Job
Talking out of his ass. can't decide whether to talk about god as a symbol or as a walking reality with contradictions, and never really explains how it relates to man at the time as it sets out to do, instead just saying the same thing over and over again, "god wants to be man", and referencing his archetypes. I like when he actually stays on topic in the subject of The Book of Job, otherwise, a bore. Skip. I need to read his fundamentals. Also, the Bible. I'll prob change standpoint andWhen dealing with the contradictions in the Bible, this book is on fire. Its main interpretation of the Book of Job has changed the way I think about it. However, as one of the early psychoanalysts, Jung applies his garbage theory in barely readable pose. Sometimes it was so convoluted I read sentences and paragraphs several times over and still couldnt quite figure what he was saying. In short, this is occasionally insightful, but for the most part is schlock and a dreadful read.
The back cover advertises Answer to Job as "one of Jung's most controversial works." He wrote it toward the end of his life, in the early 1950s, and according to the introduction to the 2010 edition by Sonu Shamdasani, he composed it in a kind of fever and later considered it the only one of his works he would not wish to alter. A short, swift book, written in a dryly sardonic style, it is a plea to update Christianity, or monotheism more generally, so that it can face the dangers of the atomic
Even now after having just finished the book I find myself equally confused and apathetic toward the entire process of reading it. I thought that Rogers was tangential in his writing but this is even worse. I was afraid that the introduction notes were a sign of what was to come, and my fears were well established halfway through the book.From the best of what I understand, Jung psychoanalyzed God and Christianity, but with his own brand of psychoanalysis or analysis or whatever it was. For
The short answer is that God's answer to Job was "Jesus Christ". However, Jung takes 140 pages to give the long answer, which will lose or bewilder traditional Christians. If you are "Jung at heart", though, these ideas should not be too surprising: that the psyche is real, that God is reality itself, and that God was found to be incomplete by Job's inquiry, fueling God's desire to become man in the flesh. This is not easy reading, but then, I don't know of anyone else who has given the question
In Jung's dense and wild meditation on Christianity, published nine years before his death, he seeks some lofty antecedents, but lets his fast and loose language of archetype cover for some questionable footwork.Jung clearly built his book as an homage to Kierkegaard's Fear and Trembling, substituting the philosopher's exegesis of Isaac and Abraham for an inquiry into the nature of Job. For Kierkegaard, several Rashoman-like retellings of the story eventually yield to furious, brooding analysis
Not an easy book to read, as Jung was overfond of technical terms such as "chthonic" and "quaternity." Still, after having encountered the Old Testament God in the Book of Job, I was greatly disturbed by His capriciousness and even amorality. Jung helped explain how the misbehavior of Yahweh led eventually to Christianity.
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.